Celebrating 26 tasty years in Lewis Center

26 years of good pizza, good people, and saying yes as often as we can. There’s a lot of heart behind this place.

Proud to be a Friday Night Staple

We’re honored to be the official sponsor of Olentangy-Orange Football Games. Supporting local students, families, and community traditions is part of how we show up—and we wouldn’t want it any other way.

Person wearing an apron standing in a kitchen or bakery, with stacked boxes and trays of baked goods or food items in the background.
Close-up of ezzo pepperonis.

Check out the menu

What’s New

Kale Caesar salad with croutons and grated cheese in a white bowl on white background.

Build Your Own Salad

Start with lettuce and dressing. Choose from toppings like green peppers, green olives, black olives, red onions, banana peppers, diced tomatoes, crunchy pepperoni, bacon, extra cheese, fresh mozzarella, croutons, or fried chicken. Your first 3 toppings are free — add as many more as you’d like for a small additional charge.

O-shaped bread with a small container of marinara sauce in the center, on a metal tray, with a bowl of salad, a cup of soup, a wine glass, and a red and white checkered tablecloth.

Tarant-O’s

Shaped like the letter everyone’s wearing on Saturdays. Golden, chewy, and perfect for dipping. Comes with two sauces: Garlic Parm, Sun-Dried Tomato Garlic, or Pesto Garlic.

CHECK OUT THE FULL MENU

Kid’s DIY Pizza

STOP IN & SAY HELLO

1282 E Powell Rd, Lewis Center, OH

A top-down view of a table with a large pizza, a bowl of salad with lettuce, cherry tomatoes, and carrots, two small bowls of dressing, a pair of sunglasses, and a red drinking glass. Two people are reaching for items on the table, with one wearing a yellow sweater.

DELIVERY
OR PICKUP

Hand holding a stack of five empty white foam food containers against a beige wall.

How We Do Pizza

Frozen dough balls in a plastic bag on a stainless steel surface.

Fresh Dough

We make our dough fresh—every day. It’s the foundation of everything we do, and we treat it that way. Time, care, and consistency matter here. Cutting corners isn’t our thing.

A person spreading marinara sauce onto pizza dough at a kitchen table.

Secret’s in the Sauce

Our sauce is house-made and closely guarded (yes, really). It’s where a lot of the magic lives—balanced, bold, and unmistakably ours.

Close-up of ezzo pepperonis.

Quality Toppings

We choose ingredients that taste good because… they should. Thoughtful sourcing, balanced flavors, and no filler for the sake of convenience. If it goes on the pizza, it earns its place.

Events at Taranto’s

A person's hand with red nail polish holding a black wire bingo cage filled with colorful bingo balls against a beige wall.

  • The last Wednesday of the month from 6:30 to when the prizes are all gone!

  • The first Thursday of every month.

Bingo cards, pepperoni slices, a glass of water, and a drink on a red and white checkered tablecloth.
Book the Patio for a Private Event